
Disney's Wilderness Lodge
Best for families and guests who want a Magic Kingdom boat connection and a dramatic lodge atmosphere.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Disney's Wilderness Lodge is a Northwest–style, family-friendly Bay Lake resort with quick boat access to Magic Kingdom; read this if you want a dramatic lodge setting close to the park. Disney's Old Key West Resort is a relaxed, Florida Keys–inspired Disney Vacation Club property with spacious villa-style rooms; read this if you prefer roomy villas and a laid-back lakeside pace.
Updated

Best for families and guests who want a Magic Kingdom boat connection and a dramatic lodge atmosphere.

Best for travelers who need larger villa-style accommodations and a low-key, long-stay feel.
When Disney's Wilderness Lodge wins: choose Wilderness Lodge if you want the shortest, easiest boat ride to Magic Kingdom, lodge-style public spaces, multiple table-service and quick-service dining options, and family-focused pool amenities including a waterslide.
When Disney's Old Key West Resort wins: pick Old Key West if you need 1- or 2-bedroom villas or Extended-stay style rooms, prefer a Florida Keys–quiet layout, or are booking a Disney Vacation Club villa with full kitchen conveniences.
Bottom line: both are relaxed Disney resorts that appeal to families, but Wilderness Lodge is the choice for proximity and themed dining/pool experiences near Magic Kingdom; Old Key West is the practical choice for bigger villa rooms and a quieter, Keys-style atmosphere.
| Category | Disney's Wilderness Lodge | Disney's Old Key West Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Northwest–style national‑park lodge, dramatic lobby and pine-forest setting | Laid-back, Florida Keys–inspired, resort-villa neighborhood |
| Location relative to parks | On Bay Lake with complimentary boat service to Magic Kingdom | Lake Buena Vista area near Disney Springs and short drive to parks |
| Size / room types | Standard rooms plus Boulder Ridge Villas and Copper Creek Villas & Cabins (approx. 300+ standard rooms; additional villas on property) | Large resort with 761 rooms including Deluxe Studio, 1 Bedroom Villa and 2 Bedroom Villa |
| Ages / audience | All-ages, family-focused with children’s activities and supervised childcare (surcharge) | All-ages, family-friendly Disney Vacation Club–style resort |
| Pools & water | Two heated outdoor pools (Copper Creek Springs main pool with 67‑ft waterslide; Boulder Ridge Cove quieter zero‑entry pool) plus hot tubs | Outdoor pool(s), children's pool and one hot tub listed; marina and lake activities nearby |
| Restaurants & bars | Several options: Whispering Canyon Cafe, Story Book Dining at Artist Point with Snow White, Roaring Fork, Geyser Point Bar & Grill, Territory Lounge | One main restaurant and one bar/lounge listed; cooked-to-order breakfasts available for a fee |
| Spa & fitness | Sturdy Branches Health Club (fitness center and sauna); spa services are not currently offered on-site (guests referred to Grand Floridian Spa) | Fitness facilities listed; on-site full spa services not published |
| Known for | Lodge theming, Magic Kingdom boat access, waterslide and character/interactive dining | Spacious villa accommodations and a relaxed Keys-style atmosphere |
| Parking & transport | Bus service to other parks; boat to Magic Kingdom; self-parking and valet available for a fee | Complimentary theme park shuttle; self-parking and valet options listed (fees apply) |
| Accessibility | Wheelchair-accessible rooms available among standard rooms and villas | Multiple accessible room descriptions (wheelchair and hearing accessible) across room types |
Disney's Wilderness Lodge sits on Bay Lake in the Magic Kingdom Resort Area and offers direct boat service to Magic Kingdom.
Choose Wilderness Lodge if you prioritize the quickest resort-to‑Magic Kingdom connection and a lakefront lodge setting.
Disney's Old Key West Resort is a lakeside Lake Buena Vista property near Disney Springs and several Disney golf and recreation options.
Pick Old Key West if you want a quieter, spread-out resort near Disney Springs with easy driving or shuttle access to parks.
Wilderness Lodge offers standard hotel rooms plus on-site villa options (Boulder Ridge and Copper Creek Villas & Cabins).
Wilderness Lodge mixes lodge-style standard rooms with Disney Vacation Club–style villas at the same address.
Old Key West is primarily configured as Disney Vacation Club villas and larger units focused on space and self-catering.
Old Key West is the practical option when you need a 1- or 2-bedroom villa or a room with kitchen facilities.
Wilderness Lodge provides multiple table-service and quick-service options plus a lounge, covering a range from character dining to poolside grill fare.
Wilderness Lodge offers more and varied on-site dining experiences, including character and signature-style options.
Old Key West lists one restaurant and one bar/lounge with cooked-to-order breakfasts available for a fee.
Old Key West is simpler on dining—plan to use transportation to visit more dining options off-property or at other Disney resorts.
Wilderness Lodge’s standout aquatic feature is Copper Creek Springs Pool with a themed waterslide and family activities.
If a themed family pool and waterslide matter, Wilderness Lodge is the stronger pick.
Old Key West has outdoor pool facilities, a children's pool and a hot tub, and offers lake recreation and marina access.
Old Key West suits guests who want standard pool options plus lake recreation rather than a themed waterslide experience.
Wilderness Lodge has a 24-hour fitness center (Sturdy Branches Health Club) and a lounge for evening drinks; full spa services are not currently offered on-site.
Wilderness Lodge covers fitness needs well; for spa treatments guests are directed to the Grand Floridian Spa off-property.
Old Key West lists fitness facilities and sauna among its amenities; on-site full spa services are not published.
Old Key West offers basic fitness and waterfront recreation, but a dedicated on-site day‑spa is not published.

Disney's Wilderness Lodge — direct complimentary boat service to Magic Kingdom and lakefront location.

Disney's Old Key West Resort — multiple 1- and 2-bedroom villa options and Deluxe Studios geared toward longer stays.

Disney's Wilderness Lodge — several table-service venues including character dining and a lakeside grill.

Disney's Old Key West Resort — Florida Keys–inspired atmosphere and spread-out villa grounds.
Disney's Wilderness Lodge — it has direct boat service to Magic Kingdom and sits on Bay Lake.
Disney's Old Key West — it lists Deluxe Studio, 1 Bedroom Villa and 2 Bedroom Villa configurations and 761 rooms total.
Wilderness Lodge currently has a fitness center (Sturdy Branches Health Club) but spa services are not offered on-site; guests are referred to the Grand Floridian Spa. Old Key West does not publish on-site full spa services.
Yes. Both resorts are all-ages and list family amenities such as children's pools and supervised childcare/activities (surcharge).
Explore how Disney's Wilderness Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·